Picky Eating: Not Just a Phase - SubLuna

Picky Eating: Not Just a Phase

If your child’s dietary preferences are limited to beige foods, with an aversion to anything colorful or textured, it’s easy to brush it off as typical childhood behavior. We often hear, "They’ll grow out of it" or receive advice like, "When they're hungry, they’ll eat—don't offer alternatives." But what if picky eating is actually a sign of something more serious, not just a behavioral phase?

Understanding Picky Eating: A Sign of Something Deeper

Part of raising thriving children is addressing the root cause of behaviors rather than just suppressing them. Picky eating is rarely a simple preference. Often, it’s a physiological response to two underlying issues: low stomach acid and nutrient deficiencies. These can lead to a cycle of more aversions and deficiencies if ignored.

🧠 Why Stomach Acid Matters

Digestion begins in the brain. When a child sits down to eat, the body needs to enter a parasympathetic state (rest and digest), which triggers the stomach to produce hydrochloric acid. But if this signal is weak, or if the child is stressed, overtired, or nutritionally depleted, stomach acid production suffers.

Low stomach acid (hypochlorhydria) is common, even in children. Many symptoms, such as bloating, gassiness, meat aversion, and a preference for “easy” foods, are often misdiagnosed as picky eating rather than a digestive issue.

Without adequate stomach acid:

  • Proteins aren’t broken down properly, leading to discomfort and aversion to meat.

  • Key minerals like zinc and iron aren’t absorbed.

  • Gut bacteria becomes imbalanced.

  • The immune system weakens.

  • Cravings for simple carbs and sugars increase.

When stomach acid is low, children aren’t necessarily being difficult by refusing food—they’re just being intuitive.

🛑 How to Help

One of the simplest ways to support digestion is by giving the body time to reset between meals. Frequent snacking prevents the stomach from fully resting and rebuilding acid stores, leading to further digestive issues and reinforcing picky eating.

Try:

  • Stick to three solid meals a day with set snack windows (no open kitchen policy).

  • If a snack is needed, choose something nourishing—like bone broth, egg yolks, or a small piece of cheese.

For extra support, consider:

  • Digestive enzymes before meals, especially with protein-rich foods (great for picky eaters as they are easy to consume).

  • Herbal bitters in water before or between meals to stimulate digestion (just 1–2 drops can make a difference).

  • Calc Phos Homeopathic Cell Salt to naturally boost stomach acid.

⚠️ The Deficiency Cycle: How It Fuels Picky Eating

The more deficient a child becomes, the more selective they tend to be about food. This creates a vicious cycle:

Poor Digestion → Food Discomfort → Food Avoidance → Nutrient Deficiency → Poor Digestion → Repeat

Common deficiencies linked to picky eating include:

  • Zinc: Vital for taste, smell, appetite regulation, and stomach acid production. Low zinc can make food taste “off” or metallic. Found in red meat, liver, and shellfish.

  • Iron: Essential for energy, focus, and immune health. Iron deficiency can lead to fatigue and cravings for sugar and carbs. Found in beef, liver, and egg yolks.

  • Magnesium: Regulates mood and muscle function, including gut muscles.

  • Vitamin B6: Supports protein metabolism and neurotransmitter balance. Low B6 can cause food aversions and mood swings.

  • Vitamin A (retinol): Essential for gut health, immunity, and digestion. Found in liver and egg yolks.

  • Saturated fats & cholesterol: From butter, tallow, egg yolk, and raw dairy, these fats are vital for brain health and satiety.

Addressing deficiencies requires a holistic approach—rebuild from the inside out.

🥩 Focus on Nutrient-Dense Foods

Rather than sneaking veggies into smoothies, focus on foods that are most nourishing and bioavailable for your child. Animal-based foods are often the best sources of the nutrients kids need.

Top nutrient-dense options for picky eaters include:

  • Grass-fed beef liver: One of the most nutrient-dense foods available.

  • Pastured egg yolks: Rich in choline, fat-soluble vitamins, and easy to digest.

  • Meat stock: Healing for the gut and rich in minerals.

  • Raw or grass-fed dairy: Provides fat, protein, and bioavailable calcium.

  • Tallow, ghee, and butter: Calorie-dense and nourishing, perfect for adding to meals.

Start small and consistently offer these foods. Over time, they can reignite a child’s appetite and curiosity.

🌿 Herbs to Support Digestion

Herbs can gently support the digestive system:

  • Chamomile: Calms nervous system tension and soothes the belly.

  • Ginger root: Stimulates appetite and warms the gut.

  • Dandelion root: A mild bitter that encourages stomach acid production.

  • Fennel seeds: Help relieve gas and bloating, especially with meat-heavy meals.

Herbal teas and tinctures are easy, kid-friendly ways to introduce these benefits.

🌱 Mineral Support Without the Greens

While we’re not against greens, they can be tough for picky eaters. Thankfully, nature offers mineral-rich herbs that provide essential nutrients:

  • Nettles: Rich in calcium, iron, magnesium, and vitamin C.

  • Oatstraw: Full of calcium, magnesium, and other calming minerals.

  • Chickweed & cleavers: Gentle detoxifiers and mineral replenishing herbs.

  • Cocoa: Mineral-rich and tasty—combine it with nutrient-dense dairy and a pinch of sea salt for a delicious nutrient boost.

✨ Pro Tips for Raising Adventurous Eaters

It’s not just about the food—it’s about the approach:

🍟 Be Consistent
 Kids love predictable foods, like chicken tenders or fries, because they stay the same in color, texture, and taste. Apply this consistency at home with familiar foods that they eat consistently. Once they’re nourished, they’ll be more open to trying new things.

🧘♀️ Reframe the Mealtime Experience

  • Let go of pressure—invite your child to explore food through touch, smell, and even cooking.

  • Stay calm—children mirror your emotions, so a relaxed parent creates a safe space for new food experiences.

🛠 Get Them Involved
 Kids are more likely to eat what they help prepare. Involve them in meal planning, grocery shopping, cooking, seasoning, and cleaning up. It fosters a sense of community and ownership.

🔍 Decode Their Cravings
 Cravings can be clues. If your child craves bread, they might need zinc or magnesium. Sugar cravings could indicate a need for quick energy. Understanding these signals helps guide better nutrition without restriction.

Picky eating isn’t just a phase—it’s a signal from the body. By addressing the underlying causes—nutrition, digestion, and mindset—you can help your child thrive.

Need support? Explore our shop for:

 

Low Iron Low stomach acid Nutrient Deficiency Picky Eating Vitamins
Previous post Next post
Back to blog